When Can the Police Lawfully Invite or Arrest a Person Over a Commercial Dispute?
The boundary between genuine criminal investigation and the improper use of police powers to enforce debts or contractual obligations.

A failed transaction can contain both civil and criminal elements. The Police may investigate a credible allegation of fraud, forgery, stealing, threats or another offence, but should not be used merely to frighten a debtor into paying a disputed contractual sum.
When an invitation is legitimate
The Police Act authorises prevention and detection of crime and the apprehension of offenders. An investigator may invite a person where a complaint discloses facts reasonably requiring explanation. The label “business dispute” does not immunise conduct that was fraudulent from the beginning.
When police involvement becomes improper
Where the complaint is only that payment is overdue, goods were not supplied as agreed or accounts are disputed, the normal remedy is a civil claim, arbitration or mediation. In Kure v Commissioner of Police, the Supreme Court strongly condemned deploying the criminal process to settle a purely civil dispute or recover a debt.
Invitation is not the same as arrest
A written invitation should ordinarily identify the office, investigator, contact and subject sufficiently for a meaningful response. A recipient should verify it through official channels, obtain counsel, preserve relevant documents and attend at the agreed time unless there is a lawful basis to seek an adjustment.
Arrest requires lawful grounds. Under section 35 of the Constitution and the Administration of Criminal Justice Act, an arrested person must be informed promptly of the reason, treated humanely and brought before a court within the constitutionally permitted period if not released.
No arrest in lieu
A relative, employee or associate should not be arrested merely because the person sought is unavailable. The Administration of Criminal Justice Act prohibits arrest in lieu. Individual criminal responsibility cannot be replaced with collective pressure.
How to respond
- Verify the invitation and obtain the complaint details available by law.
- Engage counsel early and prepare a concise chronology with supporting records.
- Attend respectfully; do not destroy evidence or coach witnesses.
- Do not sign a statement, undertaking or settlement that has not been read and understood.
- If detention or coercion becomes unlawful, counsel may seek administrative intervention, bail or judicial relief.
Key authorities
- Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1999 (as amended), ss 35, 36 and 46.
- Police Act 2020.
- Administration of Criminal Justice Act 2015, including the prohibition of arrest in lieu.
- Kure v Commissioner of Police (2020) 9 NWLR (Pt 1729) 296.
- Oceanic Securities International Ltd v Balogun (2012) (appellate authority on misuse of police machinery for civil debt recovery).